Table of Contents
Understanding the Fundamental Difference
The distinction between bearer and order cheques represents one of the most important concepts in cheque management. This difference affects who can cash the cheque, what security measures are in place, and what liability you face as the issuer.
What is a Bearer Cheque?
A bearer cheque is payable to whoever physically possesses ("bears") the instrument at the time of presentation. The key identifying features include:
- The word "bearer" appears after the payee's name
- The payee field may be left blank
- The "or bearer" clause is not struck out
Legal Framework
Under negotiable instruments law, a bearer cheque is considered a negotiable instrument that can be transferred by mere delivery. No endorsement is required, making it the most liquid but also the most risky form of cheque.
Security Risks
- 1Loss or Theft: If a bearer cheque is lost or stolen, the finder can encash it immediately
- 2No Audit Trail: There's no record of who actually received the funds
- 3Limited Recourse: Recovery options are severely limited once the cheque is cashed
What is an Order Cheque?
An order cheque is payable only to the specified payee or anyone they have formally endorsed the cheque to. Identifying features:
- Payee name is clearly specified
- "Or bearer" is crossed out
- "Or order" appears after payee name (either printed or implied)
Endorsement Requirements
For an order cheque to be transferred: 1. The payee must sign on the back of the cheque 2. The endorsement must match the payee name on the front 3. Each subsequent transfer requires additional endorsement
Types of Endorsements
Security Comparison
| Factor | Bearer Cheque | Order Cheque |
|---|---|---|
| Transfer Method | Physical delivery | Endorsement required |
| Traceability | Low | High |
| Risk of Fraud | High | Lower |
| Ease of Use | Very easy | Requires signature |
| Business Suitability | Not recommended | Recommended |
Best Practices for Businesses
For Issuing Cheques 1. Always issue order cheques for business transactions 2. Cross out "or bearer" on all cheques 3. Use "Account Payee Only" crossing for additional security 4. Record all cheque details in a cheque register
For Receiving Cheques 1. Verify endorsements match the payee name 2. Deposit promptly to reduce exposure 3. Never accept bearer cheques for large amounts 4. Check for crossing to ensure bank deposit requirement
Converting Between Types
Bearer to Order The holder can convert a bearer cheque to an order cheque by 1. Adding "Pay to [Name]" before endorsing 2. Using a restrictive endorsement
Order to Bearer An order cheque becomes a bearer instrument when 1. The payee uses a blank endorsement 2. The endorsement chain is broken
Converting an order cheque to bearer increases risk significantly.
Legal Implications
Liability of Drawer - For bearer cheques, the drawer has limited recourse if the cheque is stolen - For order cheques, the drawer can potentially recover funds if endorsement fraud is proven
Bank's Position Banks are protected when they pay bearer cheques in good faith, but have higher duty of care for verifying endorsements on order cheques.
Conclusion
For virtually all business purposes, order cheques with appropriate crossing provide the best balance of security and usability. Bearer cheques should be avoided except in very specific circumstances where immediate liquidity is essential and amounts are small.